Riley's Chhesecake
Riley's Chhesecake
More

+1.9419229604

Delicious Homemade Cheesecakes

Delicious Homemade CheesecakesDelicious Homemade CheesecakesDelicious Homemade CheesecakesDelicious Homemade Cheesecakes

Indulge in our fresh, creamy cheesecakes made with love.

Order Your Dessert Today

+1.9419229604

Delicious Homemade Cheesecakes

Delicious Homemade CheesecakesDelicious Homemade CheesecakesDelicious Homemade CheesecakesDelicious Homemade Cheesecakes

Indulge in our fresh, creamy cheesecakes made with love.

Order Your Dessert Today

About Riley's Cheesecake

Our Heritage

At Riley's Cheesecake, we take pride in our rich heritage of baking the most delicious desserts. Our recipe was handed over to us by a local guy we were buying our cakes from. He had lost his baking spot and we needed to continue this delicious journey, Sol is his name and he offered to teach me the basics. After that first bake  it has been a whirlwind of trial and error. I adopted the phrase  "Even Our Mistakes Are Delicious" Since then we have added so many flavors and different crusts and sizes, and we have continued to innovate and create new flavors that our customers love.

Indulge in our sweet creations and delights

    1/5

    Menu / Price List

    Whole Cheesecake or by the slice

    All of these cakes are made with our graham cracker crust

    Original NY

    60/8.95

    Our cakes are a full size 10" round and about 3" tall

    Salted Caramel

    60/8.95

    Made with a graham cracker dark brown sugar crust. The cake is swirled with delicious caramel and finished with Maldon sea salt flakes

    Peanut butter Chocolate

    60/8.95

    Creamy peanut butter swirled with Hershey's chocolate chips in our graham cracker crust.

    Key Lime(yes, cheesecake)

    60/8.95

    This cake is made with Nellie & Joes "Famous" Key West Lime Juice. It offers a perfect balance of sweet with the tartness of the Key Limes.

    Butterfinger

    60/8.95

    The perfect balance of  creamy and butterfingers bars.

    Snickers

    60/8.95

    The perfect balance of  creamy and chunks of snickers bars.

    Heath Bar

    60/8.95

    The perfect balance of  creamy and bits and pieces of Heath Bar.

    Reese's

    60/8.95

    This cake we make a little different. We use chunks of broken Reese's cups mixed with our smooth cream cheese and then topped with the Reese's Pieces. an excellent combination!

    Kit Kat

    60/8.95

    Another great blend of broken Kit Kats and sweet cream cheese

    Blueberry

    60/8.95

    A delicious blend of blueberries and topped with a blueberry swirls that gets sweeter when baked. So good.


    Oreo Crust cakes

    All of these cakes are made with our Oreo crust

    White Chocolate Raspberry

    60/8.95

    This is a smooth blend of raspberry and Callebaut Belgium white chocolate. Finished with Callebaut callets.

    Oreo

    60/8.95

    Delicious chucks of Oreos mixed with our creamy cheesecake.

    Double Chocolate

    60/8.95

    Made with Callebaut Dark Chocolate, cocoa and espresso. Amazing 

    Add a footnote if this applies to your business

    Contact Us

    Drop us a line!

    Attach Files
    Attachments (0)

    This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

    Better yet, see us in person!

    We love our customers, so feel free to visit during normal business hours.

    Riley's Cheesecake(Inside Rico's Pizza coolers)

    6547 Gateway Avenue, Sarasota, FL, USA

    +1.9419229604

    Hours

    Open today

    11:00 am – 10:00 pm

    We are closed for Thanksgiving, Christmas and Easter. 

    Copyright © 2025 Riley's Cheesecake - All Rights Reserved.


    Powered by

    This website uses cookies.

    We use cookies to analyze website traffic and optimize your website experience. By accepting our use of cookies, your data will be aggregated with all other user data.

    Accept